The Old Fashioned. A cocktail steeped in history, simplicity, and the unyielding power of good ingredients. At its heart lies whiskey, and for many, bourbon is the preferred spirit. But which bourbon? With countless options lining shelves, the question arises: Does Buffalo Trace, a widely respected and readily available bourbon, make a good Old Fashioned? The answer, as with many things in the realm of taste, is nuanced, but in short – yes, absolutely. Let’s delve into why.
Understanding the Old Fashioned: A Foundation for Flavor
To truly appreciate how Buffalo Trace interacts with the Old Fashioned, we need to understand the core elements of the drink itself. It’s more than just whiskey and sugar; it’s a delicate balance.
The Essential Ingredients
The classic Old Fashioned consists of four fundamental components: whiskey (bourbon or rye), sugar (often a sugar cube or simple syrup), bitters (Angostura is the traditional choice), and water (or ice dilution). An orange peel garnish is also integral, contributing aromatic oils and a touch of visual appeal. The quality of each ingredient is crucial, impacting the final result significantly.
The Art of the Build
The magic lies in the preparation. The sugar is muddled with bitters and a touch of water to create a paste. This base is then combined with the whiskey and ice. Stirring is key, chilling the drink while simultaneously diluting it to the perfect consistency. The orange peel is then expressed over the drink, releasing its oils, and added as a garnish. This process, though simple, demands attention to detail for optimal results.
Buffalo Trace Bourbon: A Profile Worth Knowing
Before assessing its suitability for an Old Fashioned, let’s examine Buffalo Trace bourbon itself. Understanding its characteristics is crucial for predicting its behavior in a cocktail.
The Distillery and Its Legacy
Buffalo Trace Distillery, located in Frankfort, Kentucky, boasts a rich history, claiming to be the oldest continuously operating distillery in America. It produces a wide range of bourbons, each with its unique character. The namesake Buffalo Trace bourbon is a flagship product, known for its approachability and value.
Tasting Notes: What to Expect
Buffalo Trace bourbon typically exhibits a profile of vanilla, caramel, and oak, with hints of spice and brown sugar. It’s a relatively balanced bourbon, neither overly sweet nor overly spicy, making it a versatile choice for various applications. The proof, generally 90, provides enough backbone to stand up in a cocktail without overpowering other ingredients. The flavor is often described as smooth and easy-drinking, characteristics that contribute to its widespread appeal.
Buffalo Trace in an Old Fashioned: A Symphony of Flavors
Now, let’s explore how Buffalo Trace performs in the context of an Old Fashioned. Does its flavor profile complement the other ingredients? Does it hold its own against the dilution and bitters?
The Marriage of Bourbon and Bitters
The combination of Buffalo Trace and Angostura bitters is a classic pairing. The vanilla and caramel notes of the bourbon soften the bitterness of the Angostura, creating a harmonious blend. The spice elements in both ingredients intermingle, adding complexity without being overwhelming. The oak notes from the bourbon contribute a subtle dryness that balances the sweetness of the sugar.
Dilution and Its Impact
Dilution is a critical aspect of an Old Fashioned. As the ice melts, it integrates the flavors, softening the bourbon’s intensity and creating a smoother, more palatable drink. Buffalo Trace, with its moderate proof, benefits from dilution, allowing its more subtle flavors to emerge. Over-dilution, however, can mute the flavors, so careful stirring is essential.
The Role of the Orange Peel
The orange peel provides a vital aromatic component. The citrus oils complement the bourbon’s vanilla and caramel notes, adding brightness and complexity. The bitterness of the peel also contributes a balancing element, preventing the drink from becoming overly sweet. Buffalo Trace’s profile pairs well with the orange notes, creating a refreshing and aromatic Old Fashioned.
Pros and Cons: Weighing the Options
While Buffalo Trace generally makes a good Old Fashioned, it’s important to consider its strengths and weaknesses compared to other bourbons.
Advantages of Using Buffalo Trace
- Availability and Affordability: Buffalo Trace is widely available and relatively affordable, making it an accessible option for most people. You can often find it at liquor stores and bars without difficulty.
- Balanced Flavor Profile: Its balanced flavor profile makes it a versatile choice for an Old Fashioned. It’s not too spicy, not too sweet, and not too oaky, allowing it to harmonize well with other ingredients.
- Smoothness and Drinkability: Buffalo Trace is known for its smooth and easy-drinking character, which translates well to an Old Fashioned. It’s a pleasant and approachable bourbon, even for those new to the spirit.
Potential Drawbacks to Consider
- May Lack Complexity for Some: Some bourbon enthusiasts may find Buffalo Trace’s flavor profile somewhat simple compared to more premium or high-rye options. While balanced, it might not offer the same depth and complexity as some other choices.
- Can Be Overwhelmed by Bold Bitters: While it pairs well with Angostura, Buffalo Trace’s subtle flavors can be overwhelmed by particularly bold or aggressive bitters. Experimentation is key to finding the right balance.
- Proof May Be Too Low for Some: For those who prefer a boozier Old Fashioned, Buffalo Trace’s 90 proof might not provide enough kick. Higher-proof bourbons can deliver a more assertive and intense flavor experience.
Beyond Buffalo Trace: Exploring Alternative Bourbons for Your Old Fashioned
While Buffalo Trace is a solid choice, the world of bourbon is vast. Experimenting with different bourbons can lead to exciting discoveries and personalized variations of the Old Fashioned.
High-Rye Bourbons: Adding a Spicy Kick
Bourbons with a higher rye content, such as Bulleit Rye Bourbon, offer a spicier and more assertive flavor profile. These bourbons can add complexity and a pleasant bite to an Old Fashioned, particularly for those who enjoy a bolder drink. The spice notes complement the bitters and provide a contrast to the sweetness of the sugar.
Wheated Bourbons: Embracing Softness and Sweetness
Wheated bourbons, such as Maker’s Mark, are known for their softer and sweeter flavor profiles. These bourbons can create a smoother and more approachable Old Fashioned, particularly for those who prefer a less intense drink. The vanilla and caramel notes are often amplified in wheated bourbons, creating a rich and decadent cocktail.
Higher-Proof Options: For a More Potent Experience
Choosing a higher-proof bourbon, such as Wild Turkey 101, can add a significant kick to your Old Fashioned. The increased alcohol content intensifies the flavors and provides a more robust drinking experience. However, it’s important to adjust the amount of bourbon used to avoid overpowering the other ingredients.
Elevating Your Old Fashioned: Tips and Techniques
Regardless of the bourbon you choose, mastering the art of the Old Fashioned involves more than just pouring ingredients into a glass. Here are some tips to elevate your cocktail game.
The Sugar Question: Cubes vs. Simple Syrup
The choice between a sugar cube and simple syrup is a matter of personal preference. A sugar cube requires muddling, which can be time-consuming and messy if not done correctly. Simple syrup dissolves easily and allows for precise sweetness control. Experiment with both to see which you prefer.
Ice Matters: Quality and Dilution
Use high-quality ice, preferably large cubes or a single large ice ball. This type of ice melts slower, minimizing dilution and preserving the flavor of the drink. Avoid using crushed ice, which melts quickly and can result in a watery Old Fashioned.
Expressing the Orange Peel: Aromatic Power
Express the orange peel correctly by squeezing it over the drink, releasing the oils onto the surface. Then, rub the peel around the rim of the glass to further enhance the aroma. Add the peel to the drink as a garnish.
Experiment with Bitters: Beyond Angostura
While Angostura is the traditional choice, don’t be afraid to experiment with other bitters. Orange bitters, chocolate bitters, and even aromatic bitters can add unique dimensions to your Old Fashioned. Start with a small amount and adjust to taste.
Conclusion: Buffalo Trace – A Reliable Foundation for a Classic Cocktail
So, does Buffalo Trace make a good Old Fashioned? The answer is a resounding yes. Its balanced flavor profile, smooth character, and wide availability make it an excellent choice for both beginners and experienced cocktail enthusiasts. While some may prefer a spicier or more complex bourbon, Buffalo Trace provides a solid foundation for a delicious and satisfying Old Fashioned. Ultimately, the best bourbon for your Old Fashioned is the one you enjoy the most. Experiment, explore, and discover your perfect recipe. And remember, the key is balance, quality ingredients, and a passion for the craft.
Does Buffalo Trace Bourbon make a good Old Fashioned?
Yes, Buffalo Trace Bourbon generally makes a very good Old Fashioned. Its mash bill #1, combined with its age and proof, lends itself well to the cocktail’s flavors. The bourbon offers a balanced profile of vanilla, caramel, and oak, which complements the sweetness of the sugar and the bitterness of the bitters without overpowering them. This makes for a harmonious and enjoyable drink.
Furthermore, Buffalo Trace is widely available and reasonably priced, making it a practical choice for a frequently enjoyed cocktail. While more premium bourbons might offer a more complex and nuanced Old Fashioned, Buffalo Trace delivers a consistently high-quality and accessible option. Its characteristically smooth finish also contributes to the overall drinkability of the Old Fashioned.
What are the key flavor components Buffalo Trace Bourbon brings to an Old Fashioned?
Buffalo Trace Bourbon contributes several key flavor components that enhance an Old Fashioned. The prominent notes of vanilla and caramel provide a foundational sweetness, working in tandem with the added sugar. The oak influence introduces a subtle dryness and complexity, adding depth to the overall flavor profile. A hint of spice, often perceived as cinnamon or nutmeg, complements the bitters and adds warmth.
Beyond these individual flavors, Buffalo Trace offers a balanced integration of its constituent parts. This balance allows the bourbon to meld seamlessly with the other ingredients, creating a cohesive cocktail experience. The bourbon’s relatively high proof (typically 90 proof) also ensures that its flavors are not diluted by the ice or other ingredients, resulting in a bold and flavorful Old Fashioned.
How does Buffalo Trace Bourbon compare to other bourbons for making an Old Fashioned?
Buffalo Trace Bourbon offers a good middle-ground option compared to other bourbons suitable for an Old Fashioned. It’s generally considered a step up from budget-friendly bourbons like Jim Beam or Evan Williams, offering a richer and more complex flavor profile. At the same time, it is less assertive than some higher-proof or more intensely flavored bourbons, such as those from Wild Turkey or Four Roses.
Ultimately, the “best” bourbon for an Old Fashioned is subjective and depends on individual preferences. Buffalo Trace provides a solid, versatile base that allows the other elements of the cocktail – the sugar, bitters, and garnish – to shine. It’s a great option for those seeking a balanced and approachable Old Fashioned, without overwhelming intensity or expense.
What kind of bitters pair best with a Buffalo Trace Bourbon Old Fashioned?
Angostura bitters are the classic and most commonly recommended bitters for an Old Fashioned, and they pair exceptionally well with Buffalo Trace Bourbon. Their spice-forward profile, featuring notes of clove, cinnamon, and allspice, complements the bourbon’s vanilla and caramel notes, creating a harmonious and balanced flavor. The subtle bitterness also cuts through the sweetness, preventing the cocktail from becoming cloying.
While Angostura is the standard, experimenting with other bitters can add interesting nuances to a Buffalo Trace Old Fashioned. Orange bitters can accentuate the citrus elements of the garnish, while chocolate bitters can add a richer, more decadent dimension. However, it’s generally best to start with Angostura to appreciate the classic combination before venturing into more experimental pairings.
What garnish is recommended for a Buffalo Trace Bourbon Old Fashioned?
The traditional garnish for an Old Fashioned, and the one that complements Buffalo Trace Bourbon particularly well, is an orange peel. The expressed oils from the orange peel release aromatic citrus notes that enhance the bourbon’s flavor profile. The oils add a brightness and complexity, lifting the overall drink and preventing it from feeling too heavy or one-dimensional.
While some people prefer adding a cherry to their Old Fashioned, it can often overwhelm the more subtle flavors of Buffalo Trace. If a cherry is desired, opt for a high-quality brandied cherry rather than a bright red maraschino cherry, which tends to be overly sweet and artificial. Ultimately, the orange peel provides the most complementary and balanced garnish for a Buffalo Trace Bourbon Old Fashioned.
How can I adjust the sweetness of an Old Fashioned made with Buffalo Trace?
The sweetness of an Old Fashioned made with Buffalo Trace can be easily adjusted to suit individual preferences. The most direct method is to modify the amount of sugar or simple syrup used. For a less sweet cocktail, reduce the sugar or simple syrup by a small increment (e.g., from 1 teaspoon to ½ teaspoon). Conversely, for a sweeter cocktail, increase the amount slightly.
Another approach is to experiment with different types of sugar or sweeteners. Brown sugar or demerara sugar can add a richer, molasses-like sweetness that complements the bourbon’s oak notes. Agave nectar offers a more subtle sweetness, while maple syrup can add a unique and complex flavor profile. Always make adjustments gradually, tasting the cocktail after each change to achieve the desired level of sweetness.
What are some common mistakes to avoid when making an Old Fashioned with Buffalo Trace?
One common mistake is over-diluting the Old Fashioned. Using too much ice, or stirring for too long, can weaken the bourbon’s flavor and make the cocktail watery. It’s best to use a large ice cube or sphere to minimize melting, and to stir gently until the cocktail is properly chilled but not excessively diluted. Another mistake is using low-quality ingredients, particularly inexpensive bitters or maraschino cherries.
Another pitfall is neglecting the importance of expressing the oils from the orange peel. Simply placing the peel in the glass won’t release its aromatic compounds effectively. Gently squeezing the peel over the glass, with the peel facing down, allows the oils to spray over the surface of the cocktail, adding a crucial element of aroma and flavor. Finally, failing to balance the ingredients – sugar, bitters, and bourbon – can result in an Old Fashioned that is either too sweet, too bitter, or too boozy. Fine-tuning the proportions is essential for achieving a harmonious and enjoyable cocktail.
Alden Pierce is a passionate home cook and the creator of Cooking Again. He loves sharing easy recipes, practical cooking tips, and honest kitchen gear reviews to help others enjoy cooking with confidence and creativity. When he’s not in the kitchen, Alden enjoys exploring new cuisines and finding inspiration in everyday meals.